Taewoo Kim v. Jump Trading, LLC

Taewoo Kim v. Jump Trading, LLC | Docket

In the United States Court of Appeals For the Seventh Circuit

A 7 *7 " @AR " $* )6 && "" ) AR ,2 R A AR # R AR $ $*)6 && "" $*) @R

MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMR

3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 (3 3 '3 '3$%3 3$&$#323 ( '3

MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMR

54A 646: Q 57A 646:R

$' R AR AR # R A 7 ( + *7 + ) @R A 7 ( + *7 + @R '' RE '' FR # R R , ' R '.%)$ *'' # (R $#R ) R '' R !$ #AR , R , (R " # R .R '' $'"R (AR R # %$' #R $"% #.@R #! R R # AR , R " #) #(R #)' ! / R ' $' (R $ R %$( )$'(JR ! # (AR R !$ #R "%!$.(R R #)' ! / R # ),$' R $ R *( '(R)$R+ ' .R R)' #( ) $#@R R, (R R)' ) $# !R '.%O )$ *'' # .AR"* R! R ) $ #AR, $( R+ !* R1* )* ) R ( R $#R(*%%!.R # R " # @R '' AR .R $#)' ()AR, (R(*%%$( R)$R R R() ! $ #AR, $( R+ !* R, (R! # R)$R($" R$) 'R (( )QPage 2 $'R '' AR) R @ @R $!! '@R R '' R $ #R, (R(*%%$( R)$R R ,$') R>5@

$()R() ! $ #(R' !.R$#R R' ( '+ R$ R #$) 'R (( )R)$R" #O ) #R) 'R+ !* @R R $ #R (R R ! "R)$R>5R #R) R' ( '+ (AR($R ) R() ! $ #R( $*! R R,$') R>5@RE )R (AR )R( $*! R R' O " ! R $'R>5R #R (( )(AR(* R (R %$( )(R )R R # @FR '' AR $, + 'AR*( R #R ' )' R" # ("R)$R" #) #R )(R+ !* @R #R ! $' ) "R !!$, R $! '(R)$R $#+ ')R R '' R $ #R #)$R R $!! 'J(R,$') R$ R R # R+ R+ '( @RE ) 'R) #R ! O ) ) R) R - # R$ R '' R $'R AR) R ! $' ) "R,$' R .R ()'$. # R R '' R $ #R # R" #) # R R)$R' %! R )R$'R .R ()'$. # R R # R" #) # R R '' @FR #AR R) R" 'O )R%' R$ R '' R ! # R !$,R>5AR ' )' *'(R $*! R *.R )AR $#+ ')R) R '' R #)$R R $!! 'R$ R AR # R( !!R) R AR %'$0) # R '$"R) R(%' @R $R!$# R (R) (R(%' R, (R ' ) 'R ) #R) R $()R$ R)' # AR #+ ()$'(R,$*! R *.R '' R # R $#O + ')R )R)$R R$'R $#+ ')R '' R) .R !' .R$,# @R #R%' #O %! AR) (R,$*! R' ()$' R '' J(R%' R)$R>5@

'' $'"J(R ' )' R" # ("R), R ! R)$R %R )(R + !* R )R>5@R $) R) " (AR '' J(R%' R ! # AR # R, ! R #O + ()$'(R $! # R '' R $*! R $#+ ')R )R)$R AR $'R+ ' $*(R ' ($#(R) (R " R*# ( ' ! @R '' $'"R, (R ! R)$R($!+ R ) R0'()R ! # AR #R6465AR .R% '(* # R *"%R ' # R)$R *.R " !! $#(R$ R '' R $ #(R #R - # R $'R$%) $#(R)$R *.R R %!.@R *"%J(R%*' ( R' ()$' R) R%' R$ R '' R)$R>5@R *)R #() R$ R%'$ ! " # R *"%J(R'$! AR '' $'"R%' ) # R) )R ) R ' )' R" # ("R R' ()$' R '' J(R%' @R $' O # R)$R) R $"%! #)AR )R, (R) #R) )R #+ ()$'(Q*# , ' R$ R *"%J(R'$! R *' # R) R0'()R ' ( (Q $* )R '' AR)'*() # R) R ' )' R" # ("@R #R )R ! R #AR #R6466AR '' J(R %' R $!! %( @R (R) " R *"%R #J)R #) '+ # @R '' $'"R !) R !!R)' # R # R0! R $'R # '*%) .@R $*)R>84R !! $#R #R#$" # !R+ !* R+ # ( @

Page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

+ , !3 3 3 !3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 1 (3 3 (3 3 !3 3 3 3 . 3 (3 !3 3 (3 3 !3 3 3 3 3 3 3! 3 !3 3 3 3 3 (3 1 3) 3 3 3 *3 !3 3 3 !3 3 3 1 !3)/ 0*(3 3 3 3 3 3" !3 3 !3 1 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3)/ 3 0*'

*"%R ' * (R) )R "R #J)R(* R )R ) 'R *( R )AR)$$AR # O 0)(R '$"R) R ' " #)@R )R"$+ R #R) R ()' )R $*')R)$R $"O % !R ' )' ) $#@R ) 'R )R R($R*# 'R=R @ @ @RN8R$'RN64:R (R *# ! 'CR) R"$) $#R" #) $#(R# ) '@R *"%R( .(R) )R= @ @ @R N646R $+ '#(R) R ' )' ) $#R ' " #)R ), #R "R # R 'O ' $'"AR($R, R, !!R ((*" R) )RN64:R %%! (@R #R) R ()' )R $*')R # R *"%J(R' &* ()AR( R6469R @ @R ()@R R<<<=<R E @ @R !!@R .R=AR6469FAR )R %% ! R*# 'R=R @ @ @RN5:E F@R

*"%R #$,! (R) )R )R (R#$)R R% ').R)$R) R ' " #)R ), #R "R # R '' $'"@R #() AR )R( .(R) )R) R $ )' # R $ R &* ) ! R ()$%% !R' &* ' (R "R)$R ' )' ) AR( # R "R (R (* # R *"%R $'R $# * )R #R , R '' $'"R , (R R $O $#O (% ' )$'@R #R *"%J(R + ,AR R ! ,(* )R #()R )R ,$*! R #.RPage 4 '' $'"R ) R # 0)R $ R ) R ' )' ) $#R ' " #)R *( R *"%R" .R(* R '' $'"R $'R $#)' *) $#@R # R) )R,$*! R $' R '' $'"R )$R ! ) ) AR ' ) 'R ) #R ' )' ) AR &* () $#(R $*)R )(R" ( $# * )@R )R '' $'"R # R )(R(* (($'R #R # O '*%) .R + R# ) 'R #) '+ # R#$'R0! R #R " *(R ' R)$R (*%%$')R *"%Q*# '() # !.R($@R R 'R ) R $'R ! "(R #R ) R # '*%) .R (R% (( AR # R '' $'"J(R' " # # R (( )(R ' R ! R #R R! &* ) # R)'*()R '$"R, R *"%R ##$)R # O 0)@R )R" (R R(* )R .R *"%R #()R '' $'"R*#! !.@ 7

*"%R#$# ) ! ((R $#) # (R) )R #R ' )' )$'AR' ) 'R) #R R $*')AR( $*! R R) R ((* R$ R &* ) ! R ()$%% !@R )R' (R ) R %$') $#R $ R ) R ' " #)R ' &* ' # R ' )' ) $#R $ R K #.R ! "R$'R $#)'$+ '(.R (R)$R ' )' ! ).LR)$R" #R) )R, #O + 'R) ' R (R R (%*) R, ) 'R R) ' R% ').R #R # $' R) R ' " #)AR) )R (%*) R"*()R R ' )' ) @R # R )R%$ #)(R)$R ! # * R '$"R ) R *%' " R $*')J(R ( $#R #R %-) #7,27 $7 0 (7 .$%" )37 $ 2 AR97;R @ @R;=RE6446FAR # R$*'R$,#R #R $ R ,27 + )* (7 & * "7 %(&2 AR:59R @7 R;79RE;) R '@R6454FAR) )R )R) # (R $"% !(R) (R $# !*( $#@R $ ) 'AR) ( R ' *" #)(R %' ( #)R),$R&* () $#(BR0'()AR, $R (Q) R $*')R$'R #R 'O )' )$'Q) R" ' )(R$ R *"%J(R &* ) ! R ()$%% !R ' *" #)DR # R( $# AR R R $*')R (AR (R *"%R #) )! R)$R ' )' ) R #()R "D 7

' )' ) $#R (R $#)' )* !CR R $*')R #R $"% !R )R$#!.R R) R % ') (R + R ' R )$R ' )' ) @R 1 7 $%"% )37 $ 27 ,27 %##+$ * %$)7 %(! () AR 8;9R @ @R:87AR:8<P8=RE5=<:F@R ') (R #R ' R)$R ' )' ) R (%*) (R $*)R ' )' ! ).AR, R ( R , ) 'R R (* () #) + R (%*) R ( $*! R R ' )' ) R $'R ! ) O ) @R "R # R '' $'"R ' R)$R $R) )R #R) R) '"(R$ R ( '+ @R $'R - "%! AR) .R,$*! R# R)$R ' )' ) R R (%*) R $*)R, ) 'R "J(R ! "(RE) R($*' R$ R) R(* () #) + R! O !R (%*) FRK ' (G HR$*)R$ R$'R' ! )G HR)$LR) R) '"(Q # AR R ) .R AR "R,$*! R# R)$R ' )' ) R) "@R *"%R( .(R) )RPage 5 #R ' )' )$'R !($R"*()R R, ) 'R &* ) ! R ()$%% !R' O &* ' (R "R)$R ' )' ) R (R(* () #) + R! !R ! "(R #()R )@R )J(R *( AR #R )(R+ ,AR *"%J(R &* ) ! R) $'.R%' ( #)(R RK ! "R$'R $#)'$+ '(.R (R)$R ' )' ! ).L@R R %-) # AR97;R @ @R )R<8CR $ AR:59R @7 R )R;87@R

*)R $' R # R, ) 'R &* ) ! R ()$%% !R (R R&* (O ) $#R$ R ' )' ! ).AR, R"*()R R, ) 'R "R # R *"%R + R ' R)$R ' )' ) R $. R&* () $#(@R ' )' ) $#R (RK()' )!.R R" 3 'R$ R $#( #)ALR % $ ) 37 $ 27,27 +)! AR:46R @ @R587AR58<R E6468FRE ) ) $#R$" 3 FARK R, .R)$R' ($!+ R) $( R (%*) (Q *)R$#!.R) $( R (%*) (Q) )R) R% ') (R + R ' R)$R(* O " )R)$R ' )' ) $#@LR @RE&*$) # R ()*7 &* %$)7% 7 %37 $ 27 ,27 &" $ AR 958R @ @R=7<AR=87RE5==9FF@RK $#( &* #)!.AR) R0'()R &* () $#R #R #.R ' )' ) $#R (%*) R"*()R BR )R + R * ) 7 & (* ) R ' R)$DL 7 @RE "% ( (R F@R "R # R *"%R O + #J)R ' R)$R ' )' ) @R "R # R '' $'"R + AR($R *"%J(R ()R $% R$ R ' )' ) # R) R ((* R$ R &* ) ! R ()$%% !R,$*! R R (R R) ' O% ').R # 0 '.R$ R) 'R ' " #)@R R %( " )6 %) 7 ,27 +"*+( "7 ( 37 $ 2 AR 585R @8) R 745AR 74=P54R E5()R '@R 6469F@R )R )R $ (R#$)R $#) # R) )R )R( ) (0 (R) R' &* ' " #)(R $ R) (R $ )' # @R

$R (R, ) 'R *"%R (R' )(R*# 'R) )R ' O " #)DR )R"*()R R R $*')@R (R) R *%' " R $*')R -%! # R #R $*6 6 $* (37 )*37 $ 2 R ,27 !)%$ AR 9:5R @ @R :7AR ;5R E6454FAR $*')(R R#$)R$#!.R, ) 'R% ') (R + R ' R)$R ! O ) R &* () $#(R $ R ' )' ! ).R )$R #R ' )' )$'AR *)R !($R , ) 'R # R .R, $"R #R ' " #)R ! ) # R) ( R&* (O ) $#(R #R R # $' @R #R $*6 6 $* ( R$# R$ R) R% ') (R 'O * R) )R #R ' " #)R)$R ' )' ) R(* () #) + R (%*) (R, (R +$ @R R *() (R ! R) )R #R ' )' )$'R,$*! R# R)$R R , ) 'R) )R, (R)'* AR( # R) R% ') (R R ' R)$R ' O )' ) R&* () $#(R$ R ' )' ! ).@R *)R )R,$*! R + R !! #R)$R R $*')AR#$)R #R ' )' )$'AR)$R R, ) 'R) R ' " #)R)$RPage 6 ' )' ) R&* () $#(R$ R ' )' ! ).R, (R # $' ! R R) R% 'O ) (R R !! # R )RE' ) 'R) #R) R ' " #)R)$R ' )' ) R (* () #) + R (%*) (F@R

*()R($R ' @R "R" .R + R ' R)$R ' )' ) R) R&* (O ) $#R, ) 'R) ' R% ') (R #R # $' R (R(* () #) + R ' )' O ) $#R ' " #)R , ) R '' $'"@R *)R R $*')R "*()R R , R ) ' R % ') (R #R # $' R ) R ' " #)R )$R ' )' ) R K ! "G(HR$'R $#)'$+ '(G (HR (R)$R ' )' ! ).L@R ) ', ( AR #O .$# R $*! R # 0)R '$"R R()' # 'J(R ' " #)R)$R ' )' ) R ) ( R&* () $#(R, ) $*)R + 'R # R R% ').R)$R )Q R' (*!)R) )R ) R$' # '.R! ,R$ R $#)' )(R $ (R#$)R !!$,@R # R) R ' !R ' )' ) $#R )R $ (R #$)R K ! + ) R G ' " #)(R )$R ' )' ) R &* () $#(R$ R ' )' ! ).HR$+ 'R$) 'R $'"(R$ R $#)' )@LR $*6 6 $* ( AR9:5R @ @R )R;5@R

(R " #(R ) )R * (AR #$)R #R ' )' )$'AR "*()R R , ) 'R) R ' " #)R ), #R "R # R '' $'"R)$R ' O )' ) R ' )' ! ).R + (R ' )(R )$R *"%@R *"%R ( .(R ) )R ! #O * R' &* ' # R "R)$R ' )' ) R ! "(R ( R$#R '' $'"J(R " ( $# * )Q$'R ( R$#RK )(R$'R$" (( $#(R $'R, R.$*R G "HR " .R $#) # R ) )R , R G '' $'"HR ' R ! ! LQ + (R ' )(R)$R $O $#(% ' )$'(R #R) )R" ( $# * )AR *)R) R) -)R $"O % !(R ) R $%%$( ) R $# !*( $#BR ) )R "R ' R )$R ' )' ) R , ) R '' $'"R$#!.@R R $7( 7 +*%#%* , 7 (*)7 $* *(+)*7 * 6 * %$ AR =95R @7 R7;;AR7<9RE:) R '@R6464FRE '$ R( $% R$ R (O %*) (R $+ ' R .R ! ) ' !R ' )' ) $#R ' " #)R R#$)R *(O ) .R %%!. # R ' " #)R)$R ' )' ) R ' )' ! ).R)$R) ' R% 'O ) (FCR ( # (7,27 %.%* 7 %*%(7 %(&2 AR;49R @7 R5566AR556;P6<RE=) R '@R6457F@RR $#( 'R !($R) R *!)R'*! R #R() ) R! ,R) )RK R #G#$)HR ! "R' )(R*# 'R R $#)' )R) )R (R$#!.R R # R R (R% ') (@LR 7 $* "" $*7 %"+* %$)7 $ 27,27 ( * " 7 $ 2 AR 7:R @8) R;65AR;68RE;) R '@R6466FCR %( " )6 %) AR585R @8) R )R74=P 54@R R $#J)R( R #.) # R #R) R) -)R) )R !) '(R) (R *!)@R $R R *"%R # R "R ! R #R ' " #)R )$R ' )' ) RPage 7 ' )' ! ).AR # R R *"%R $ (#J)R + R' )(R)$R # $' R 'O ' $'"J(R ' " #)R, ) R "AR) #R R $*')R"*()R' ($!+ R )(R ' *" #)R $*)R &* ) ! R ()$%% !@R

+ # R R) )R) R ()' )R * R, (R' )R)$R # !./ R *"%J(R &* ) ! R ()$%% !R ' *" #)AR' ) 'R) #R! + R )R)$R ) R ' )' )$'AR, R#$,R' + ,R 'R ( $#R$#R) R" ' )(@R R ()' )R * R %%! R !! #$ (J(R+ '( $#R$ R &* ) ! R ()$%% !AR 0# # AR $'' )!.R #R$*'R+ ,AR) )R !! #$ (R $*')(R $' !$( R (O )$%% !R*#! ((R) R) ' R% ').R (R' ($# !.R' ! R$#R) R $#O )' )R%'$+ # R $'R ' )' ) $#@R (, $7,27 %! 37 $ 2 AR78=R !!@R %%@R 7 R94<AR958P5:RE6448FCR( R !($R +$ %7 $* ($ * %$ "7 $ 27,27 $ )+7 +$ %7 % " (7 %237 * 2 AR $@R69O6695RE;) R '@FRE ((* R $#) "%$O ' # $*(!.F@R $R$# R(* ()(R) )R %% # R ' @R

*)R , (R ) R ()' )R * R $'' )R )$R %%!.R !! #$ (R ! ,DR *"%R ' * (R) )R %) 'R6R$ R) R ' !R ' )' ) $#R )AR=R @ @ @RNNR645P4<Q, R "%! " #)(R) R $#+ #) $#R$#R) R $ # ) $#R # R # $' " #)R$ R $' #R ' )' !R , ' (RE) R ,R $' R $#+ #) $#FQ%'$+ (R) R %%! ! R! ,R$ R &* O ) ! R ()$%% !@R %) 'R6R (R( ! #)R $*)R, ) 'R) ' R% ') (R #R # $' R ' )' ) $#R ' " #)(@R ) !!AR *"%R ' * (R ) )R %) 'R6R *) $' / (R ' !R $*')(R)$R + !$%R) 'R$,#R! ,R $ R &* ) ! R ()$%% !@R (R () # (R #R $#)' ()R )$R %) 'R 5AR , R*( (R) R'*! (R$ R &* ) ! R ()$%% !R '$"R() ) R! ,@R (6 * +(7 $ () $7 7,27 (" )" AR99:R @ @R:68AR:74P75RE644=F@R

R) R ()' )R * AR, R $* )R) )R %) 'R6R $+ '#(R ) (R (%*) @R )R,$*! R $+ '#R R (%*) R ), #R "R # R 'O ' $'"R $*)R ) R # $' ! ).R $ R ) 'R ' " #)R )$R ' O )' ) AR $'R '' $'"R (R#$)R R ) / #R$ R) R # ) R ) ) (RE !)O $* R *"%R (F@R R=R @ @ @RN646@R *)R $'R) R( " R' ($#(R , R ( ) ) R)$R $%)R *"%J(R -% #( + R' # R$ R) R,$' R K ' )' ! ).LAR, R ( ) ) R#$,R)$R( .R) )R %) 'R6R ) 'O " # (R *"%J(R' )(R (R R) ' R% ').@R # 'R *"%J(R+ ,AR #.RPage 8 # #)AR( "%!.R .R (( ') # R' )(R)$R # $' R #R ' )' ) $#R ' " #)RK ' ( # R$*)R$ R R! !R' ! ) $#( %LR ), #R R )O / #R$ R) R # ) R ) ) (R # R R $' #R$# AR,$*! R R #) )! R )$R + R) R! ,R$ R %) 'R6R R (R' )(R)$R # $' R) R ' " #)R (R R) ' R% ').AR#$R" 3 'R $,R' "$) R) R! ) #)R (R '$"R) R $#)' )R%'$+ # R $'R ' )' ) $#@R *"%J(R' # R ,$*! R !!$,R #R #) ).R)$R # 0)R '$"R #R ' )' ) $#R ' O " #)J(R() )*(R*# 'R %) 'R6R $' R # R, ) 'R )R (R (* )R )$R ) )R ' " #)R )R !!@R )AR (R ) R ()' )R * R %)!.R%*)R )AR,$*! R%*)R) R ')R $' R) R $'( @R

R !($R + R( ' $*(R $* )(R $*)R *"%J(R(* () $#R) )R 7 $ ( .7 %- (7 %$, () %$7 ( $ 7 37 %(&27,27 +*%!+#&+7 * $" ))7 37 AR9=4R @ @R876RE6464FAR% '" )(R ' !R $*')(R )$R + !$%R R $""$#R! ,R$ R &* ) ! R ()$%% !R, ) R' (% )R )$R $#)' )(R $+ '# R .R %) 'R6@R ' R) R *() (R ! R ) )R#$) # R #R) R() )*) R%' + #)(R ' !R $*')(R '$"R %%!.O # R K $" () LR $ )' # (R $ R &* ) ! R ()$%% !R )$R ( (R #O +$!+ # R) ( R $#)' )(@R #R) R # ) R ) ) (AR) R%' + ! # R K $" () LR $ )' # (R$ R &* ) ! R ()$%% !R ' R $*# R #R() ) R ! ,@R (* +(7 $ () $7 ) !!(R*(R) )R %) 'R5R$ R) R ' !R 'O )' ) $#R )R $ %(&%( * )7 () ) R $ )' # (R$ R &* ) ! R ()$%% !AR $ + ) # R) R# R $'R ' !R'*! (@R99:R @ @R )R:74P75@R R 7 $ ( .7 ) (R) )R %) 'R6R" # ) (R) R %%! ) $#R$ R $O " () R $ )' # (R$ R &* ) ! R ()$%% !AR # R() ) R! ,R%'$+ (R ) $( R $ )' # (Q # !* # R, ) R' (% )R)$R ' )' ) $#R ' O " #)(Q) #R ) ' R ( $*! #J)R R #.R # R )$R ' ) R ' !R $ )' # (R$ R &* ) ! R ()$%% !@R R !($R )) ( (7,27 .)) $6 %($ # )/ 7 %"" * %$7 %+$ * %$ AR9=:R @ @R54;AR55:P5;RE6466F@R

)R*(R%*)R) (R R 2 ' #)R, .@R ' !R $*')(R ' ) R $ O )' # (R$ R ' !R! ,R, #R# (( '.R)$R($!+ R (%*) (R ' ( # R *# 'R ' !R() )*) (@R $'R - "%! AR) R "%!$. R ) ' " #)R # $" R *' ).R )RE FR' &* ' (R%! #(JR(%$#($'(R)$R %R ) R%'$" ( (R) .R" R)$R,$' '(R #R, ! ' O # 0)R%! #(@RPage 9 (R'*! R #R R # $' R$#!.R .R %%!. # R $ )' # (R$ R $#O )' )R ! ,Q, AR # R ( #)R '$"R AR ' !R $*')(R "*()R $%)@R + #R) #AR $, + 'AR) R ' !R $ )' # (R ' R O ($' R '$"R() ) R! ,R' ) 'R) #R # R ' ) R$*)R$ R, $! R !$) @R AR @ @AR 1 7 %".# ()7 37 7,27 ! 0 AR 9;8R @ @R 86;RE6459F@R R !($R 7 $ +)*( "7 2 27,27 ) AR9<7R @ @R577AR 579P7:RE645<FRE %%!. # RK$' # '.R%' # %! (R$ R $#)' )R! ,LR )$R #) '%' )R $!! ) + O ' # # R ' " #)(R $+ '# R .R ' !R! $'R! ,F@R %) 'R6R$ R) R ' !R ' )' ) $#R )AR , R $ (R#$)R( .R$# R,$' R $*)R ()$%% !AR $ (R#$)R# R $"%! ) $#R) '$* R ' !R $""$#R! ,@R

)R %) 'R6R $ (R( .R (R) )R %) 'R5R $+ '#(R, ) R ' (% )R)$R !!R(* )(R#$)R $+ ' R #R %) 'R6R$'R) R ,R $' R $#+ #) $#@R=R @ @ @RN64<@R ()$%% !R (R$# R$ R) $( R(* O )(R $" 3 R '$"R %) 'R 6Q *)AR % 'R (* +(7 $ () $ AR (R $+ ' R #R %) 'R5R) '$* R) R # $'%$' ) $#R$ R() ) R! ,@R )R $!!$,(R) )R() ) R! ,R $#)'$!(R (%*) (R $*)R ()$%% !R*#O 'R %) 'R6R (R, !!@R

R' $ # / R) )R $*'R ' * )(R + R ! R) )R ' !R $"O "$#R! ,R%'$+ (R) R'*! R$ R &* ) ! R ()$%% !R $'R ' O " #)(R $+ '# R .R %) 'R6@R 0.7,27 ( $ , )7 + $ " . 7 AR 7R @8) R55::RE=) R '@R6465FC 7 $* ( $7 2 27,27 ( $ AR 788R @7 R578AR587P88RE5()R '@R6447FCR # * 5 $(%$7 % $ ( * %$7 #6 * 7 (*$ () &37 $ 27 ,27 # * 7 % $ ( * %$7 $* ($ * %$ "37 $ @AR 5=<R @7 R <<AR =:R E6 R '@R 5===FCR $* ($ * %$ "7 & (7 %27 ,27 - )) $7 ) $ $717 $" $7 AR64:R @7 R855AR85;R #@8RE8) R '@R6444F@R R0 ) R $! (AR)$R) R $#)' '.AR) )R() ) R! ,R %%! (@R $*%$7,27 $ $7 ( %(7 $)+( $ 7 % @AR 5:5R @8) R 6<6AR 6<;P<<RE9) R '@R6469FAR% ) ) $#R $'R ') $' ' R% # # AR $@R69P 57<7@R

R ' R, ) R $*%$ R # R R) )AR + #R R, R, ' R)$R ' O ) R R ' !R '*! R $ R &* ) ! R ()$%% !AR , R ,$*! R )R ) RPage 10 ' !R '*! R '$"R () ) R ! ,@R (R ) R *%' " R $*')R ! R #R $ * 7 * * )7,27 # ""7 %% )37 $ 2 AR) R! ,R$ R) R $'*"R() ) R (*%%! (R) R ' !R'*! R*#! ((R) ' R (R R# R $'R*# $'" ).R $'R %%!. # R () ) R ! ,R ,$*! R '*()' ) R ' !R #) ' ()(@R 884R @ @R;59AR;6<P6=RE5=;=FCR( R !($R $ * 7 * * )7,27 (%-$7 '+ &6 # $*7 %(&2 AR<:R @7 R;44AR;4:P4;RE;) R '@R5==:FRE 0# # R'*! R$ R ' !R $""$#R! ,R $'R" (*' # R " (R)$R ' !R%'$%O ').R .R' ' # R)$R $'*"R() ) J(R! ,FCR )*7,27 %+ ), "" 7 )717 " *( 7 %2 AR=95R @7 R<6;AR<76RE;) R '@R6464FRE #) '%' ) # R O ' !R () )*) R 2 ) # R ( " #)(R .R!$$ # R)$R $'*"R() ) J(R ! ,R$ R%'$% ').FCR5=R ' )AR !! 'R?R $$% 'AR ( "7 ( * 7 $ 7 (% +( R N895<RE7 R @R646:FREK R *%' " R $*')R (R %*)R # ' ( # R "% ( (R$#R) R#$) $#R) )R, #R ) '" # # R ) R $#) #)R$ R ' !R $""$#R! ,AR $'*"R() ) R! ,R( $*! R R $%) R (R ' !R! ,R ( #)R($" R $$ R' ($#R)$R (%! R )LF@R

R (* +(7 $ () $7 ' &* ' (R*(R)$R # $' R ' )' ) $#R ' O " #)(R*# 'R %) 'R5R$ R) R ' !R ' )' ) $#R )R! R #.R $) 'R $#)' )BR $' # R)$R'*! (R$ R() ) R! ,@R )R $ (R#$)R%' O ( ' R *# $'" ).@R .R ( $*! R , R )' )R ' " #)(R *# 'R %) 'R6R 2 ' #)!.DR %) 'R6R $+ '(R ' " #)(R ), #R @ @R # R $' #R ) / #(AR *)R) )R( $*! #J)R" R R 2 ' # @R #) '# ) $# !R ' )' ) $#R ' " #)(R" .R $#) #R $ O$ O ! ,R ! *( (AR, R( $*! R R $#$' AR *)R ' *" #)(R '$"R $*)( R) R) -)R$ R #R ' " #)RE (R *"%J(R (FR%' (*"%) + !.R ' ()R$#R) R! ,R$ R) R $'*"R() ) @R % &)7,27 %#&%7 %" $ )37 $ 2 AR5:4R @8) R<59AR<68RE;) R '@R6469F@R ) )*) (R$'R)' ) (R" .R ' &* ' R# ) $# !R*# $'" ).AR *)R *"%R $ (R#$)R%$ #)R)$R #.@R R 0. AR7R @8) R )R55:=P;:RE AR @AR (( #) # FRE ) # R 7 $6 ( . F@R

*%%$( R) )R, R, ' R)$R ' ) R R*# $'"R ' !R'*! R$ R &* ) ! R ()$%% !@R R,$*! R() !!R# R)$R ) '" # R, ) 'R )R %%! (R$+ 'R'*! (R$ R$) 'R $*#)' (R) )R + R( # R) RPage 11 ,R $' R $#+ #) $#@R )R *"%R $ (R#$)R ( *((R) R! ,R$ R # %$' AR '' $'"J(R $" R# ) $#AR) $* R )R,$*! R + R (R ' )R R ! "R (R $ (R $""$#R! ,R #R) R # ) R ) ) (@R $'R $ (R *"%R ( R*(R)$R!$$ R)$R) R! ,R$ R) R *'$% #R # $#AR # AR - $AR % #AR$'R$) 'R)' # R% ')# '(R #R $'" # R R $ .R$ R $""$#R! ,@R

R) ' R, ' R(* R R) # R (R R ' !R $""$#R! ,R*# 'R %) 'R6AR, R,$*! R# R)$R 0# R )(R $#) #)@R #R, R + R # R)$R ' ) R*# $'"R'*! (R #R) R% ()Q (R #R ( (R #) 'O %' ) # R%! #(R*# 'R Q, R + R + !$% R) "R '$"R K$' # '.LR$'RK # ' !LR%' # %! (R$ R $#)' )R! ,@R 1 7 %"6 .# () AR9;8R @ @R )R879CR % !7,27 %#&+* (7 ))% * )7 $* ($ * %$ "37 $ 2 AR69;R @7 R;44AR;48P49RE;) R '@R6445F@R *"%J(R%'$%$( R'*! R ,$*! R !!$,R) ' R% ') (R)$R ' )' ) R ! "(R) )R !! R $ #)R " ( $# * )R .R )R # R) R( # )$'.R)$R #R ' )' ) $#R ' O " #)@R R 7 " (7 (, 7 %(&27,27 ( $!" $ AR5;;R @7 R=86AR=8;R E55) R '@R5===F@R (R'*! R $ (R#$)R( "RK$' # '.LR)$R*(@R )R ,$*! R !!$,R) ' R% ') (R)$R( R # 0)(R '$"R R $#)' )R $'R , R# ) 'R% ').R# $) ) AR %' + # R "R$ R) R # 0)R $ R (R ' #R, ) R '' $'"@R R5 $' AR "" )*%$7%$7 %$6 *( *) RN5B5RE8) R @R646:FREK R $ !R$ R $#)' )R! ,R (R)$R $! R % ') (R)$R) 'R ' " #)(R($R) )R) .R' + R) R # 0)(R$ R ) 'R ' #(@LF )R" .R" R( #( R)$R %%!.R &* ) ! R ()$%O % !R, #R R% ').R)$R R $#)' )R $ (R($" ) # R)$R" R R) ' R % ').R) # R R (R $*# R)$R )Q $'R - "%! AR R "R(* R *"%R $'R ' # R) R) '"(R$ R( '+ @R R 7 $ ( . AR9=4R @ @R )R 87;RE&*$) # R65 $' AR "" )*%$7%$7 %$*( *) RN9;B5=R )R644RE8) R @R645;FF@R *)R "R (#J)R (( ') # R R $#)' )* !R' )R #()R *"%R # AR (R 'R (R, R #R) !!AR# + 'R R #.) # R)$R" R *"%R) # R )R, (R $*# R)$R) R) '"(@R $%) # R *"%J(R'*! R " )R !($R ()*' R - () # R $"" ' !R' ! ) $#(CR% ') (R)$R O ! ) ' !R ' )' ) $#R ' " #)(R,$*! R R! )R,$# ' # R, R ) ' R% ') (AR%$(( !.R*# #$,#R)$R) "AR $*! R # $' R) 'RPage 12 ' )' ) $#R ' " #)(R #()R R%$(( ! R! ,(* )@R R # ""7 %% ) AR884R @ @R )R;6<P6=@R

*"%R' ! (R$#R $ (-( * ()7 *7 "%. 4)7,27 ( %$ +*7 $)+( $ 7 % @AR944R @7 R9;5RE;) R '@R644;FAR, R*( R R'*! R ' ,#R '$"R ' !R ! ,R $+ 'R $# R '$"R ! $'# R ! ,R , #R # R , ) 'R R " # R)$R ' )' ) R, (R) " !.@R )R ( $#R $ (R #$)R $# '#R ()$%% !Q # R )R%' (R (* +(7 $ () $ AR, R )$! R*(R)$R )R'*! (R$ R ()$%% !R '$"R() ) R! ,@R R% # !R' ! R $#R R(*%%$( R# R $'R# ) $# !R*# $'" ).R) )R) R *%' " R $*')R' ) R),$R. '(R! ) '@R *( R )R%' ) R (* +(7 $6 () $ AR) R% # !R #R ( %$ +* R !($R R#$)R $#( 'R) R 2 )R $ R=R @ @ @RN64<AR, R' '(R R)$R %) 'R5R)$R # ! R*#O %'$+ O $'R ( (@R ) + 'R $' 7 ( %$ +* R" .R + R R! "O ) R)$R) " # R&* () $#(AR )R ##$)R R -) # R)$R *() .R) R ' ) $#R$ R ' !R $""$#R! ,R $*)R ()$%% !@R

' R (#J)R #.R ' !R #) ' ()R) )R $"% !(R*(R)$R ' ) R ' !R $""$#R! ,@RR $" R $*')(R + R *() 0 R) 'R #+ #O ) $#R$ R &* ) ! R ()$%% !R $ )' # (R (R# (( '.R)$R "%! " #)R R ' !R #) ' ()R #R # $*' # R ' )' ) $#@R AR @ @AR 7 " (7 (, AR 5;;R @7 R )R=8;@R *)R %( $7,27 +$ $ 37 $ 2 AR 9=:R @ @R855AR85;P5=RE6466FAR) !!(R*(R) R$%%$( ) BR) )R) ' R (#J)R R ' !R #) ' ()R #R%'$"$) # R ' )' ) $#@R R $ !R$ R ) R ' !R() )*) R (R # $' " #)R$ R $#)' )(AR#$) # R"$' @R

(R! (R*(R R)$R !! #$ (J(R $ )' # R$ R &* ) ! R ()$%O % !AR, R' &* ' (R' ($# ! R' ! # R .R) R% ').R #+$ # R ) R ' )' ) $#R ' " #)@R *( R *"%R $ (#J)R $#) # R) )R )R' ! R$#R' %' ( #) ) $#(R .R "AR )R ##$)R*( R &* ) ! R (O )$%% !R)$R # $' R) R ' )' ) $#R ' " #)R #()R "@R $R *"%R"*()R! ) ) @R